Bad Advice vs Yes And Improv: Which Party Game Is Better?
A detailed side-by-side comparison of Bad Advice and Yes And Improv to help you choose the right party game for your next event.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Bad Advice | Yes And Improv |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Improv Games | Improv Games |
| Players | 2-100 players | 2-15 players |
| Duration | 10-20 minutes | 10-45 minutes |
| Difficulty | Easy | Easy |
| Pricing | Free | Free |
| Platforms | Web | Web |
| Rating | 3.7 | 3.9 |
Bad Advice
A free browser party game where you write confident, terrible advice for everyday problems, then vote for the worst plan. 2-100 players, no signup.
Pros
- Free to play in a browser with no signup or downloads, so anyone can join in seconds with just a room code.
- The write-then-vote-then-reveal loop is quick to learn and works for both in-person and remote groups.
- Scales comfortably from a few friends up to 100 players, making it a flexible choice for parties or calls.
- Rewarding bad ideas instead of right answers takes the pressure off and gets people laughing fast.
Cons
- Best with four or more people, so it falls a little flat in a duo where there's no one to spread voting blame around.
- Most of the fun comes from the writing, so quieter or less playful groups may need a round or two to warm up.
- There's no real scoreboard, which is part of the charm but can frustrate players who want a clear winner.
Yes And Improv
Yes And is an online improv tool built around the "Yes, and..." principle. Practice agreement and building with prompts designed for groups.
Pros
- Teaches the most foundational and transferable improv skill
- Directly applicable to workplace communication and brainstorming
- Structured exercises remove the intimidation of freeform improv
- Works for both entertainment and professional development
Cons
- Focused on a single improv principle — limited variety over time
- Can feel repetitive for experienced improvisers
- Requires willing participants — reluctant players struggle with agreement exercises
- More of a training tool than a game with winners and scores
Our Pick
This one is a close call! Bad Advice has a rating of 3.7 and Yes And Improv sits at 3.9 out of 5, making them equally strong choices for your next party game session.
The best pick comes down to what your group is looking for. Bad Advice excels at free to play in a browser with no signup or downloads, so anyone can join in seconds with just a room code., while Yes And Improv shines with teaches the most foundational and transferable improv skill. You really cannot go wrong with either one.